One of the most dangerous things we hear from families is, “Why do we need a professional interventionist? Why don’t we just talk to our loved one ourselves?”
Families also frequently say, “We’ve talked to our loved one countless times. What is it you’re going to say that’s different than what we’ve already said?”
Addicts and alcoholics carry shame and guilt that have been passed on from their families, most likely their parents. Anything said by a family member about the addict or alcoholic is likely to be perceived as criticism or shame.
No matter what or how it is said, the person on the receiving end feels pain, fear and rage and then retaliates, seeking revenge. This holds true for the family hearing from the addict or alcoholic as well.
Professional interventionists could put a microphone in family members’ ears and tell them precisely what to say to the addict or alcoholic. The message would be perceived completely differently coming from us because the loved one doesn’t resent us. The individual neither carries our guilt or shame, nor can they be blamed for any problems.
This is why families can’t do an intervention themselves. Being viewed as a problem by the loved one, they cannot offer the solution and be heard as offering anything other than criticism. This explains as well why families communicate with written letters at the intervention. Letters are designed to contain as little criticism as possible of the loved one.
Beyond what is said in the intervention, it’s also what the family does that matters. Professional drug and alcohol interventions are successful because of what is said, of course, and because the family follows through with the instructions they’ve been given.
Many outcomes can happen in an intervention. The family’s first instinct is to react as they would in any other setting, causing arguments, chaos, confusion, criticism and anger. By having a professional interventionist in charge, we’re able to keep the chaos to a minimum and to keep moving forward with the task at hand.
Without a professional present, the addict or an alcoholic can easily take control of the room and manipulate the family’s emotions, causing the intervention to go south quickly.